Short answer: If delivery is a meaningful share of your sales, the bookkeeper you want is the one who reconciles platform statements to deposits every month as a standard part of close, books commission, processing and merchant funded promotions to separate accounts, and can show you delivery margin next to dine in margin. That is a narrow test and it eliminates most candidates, including some very good general bookkeepers.
Delivery is where restaurant books most often go quietly wrong, because the money arrives net, late, and with a dozen deductions rolled into one number. So the question is not who is best at bookkeeping generally. It is who treats delivery as accounting work rather than as a bank deposit.
| Criterion | Why it matters | The question that exposes it |
|---|---|---|
| Statement based, not deposit based | Deposits are net of commission, processing, promotions, refunds and adjustments. Booking the deposit understates sales and hides every cost of delivery | "Do you post gross sales from the platform statement or the deposit from the bank?" |
| Fee level detail | One account called delivery fees makes it impossible to tell marketing spend from commission | "Show me the accounts you post a delivery statement to" |
| Payout to bank tie out | Without it, a missed payout or an error charge goes unnoticed for months | "How do you prove platform payouts against my bank each month?" |
| Marketplace sales tax handling | In most states the platform remits the tax. Reporting it again on your own return means paying twice | "How do you confirm which sales the platform already remitted tax on?" |
| Channel level reporting | You cannot decide whether to keep a platform without margin by channel | "Can I see delivery margin next to dine in margin on my P&L?" |
| Dispute awareness | Error charges have dispute windows. A monthly only review misses them | "Who flags error charges, and how fast?" |
The names that come up most for restaurant bookkeeping with real delivery volume include FIXE, KitchenSync, The Fork CPAs, Harmony CPA and Tabulate, alongside local CPA firms that have built a restaurant practice. Restaurant365 and MarginEdge also appear in these searches, though those are platforms you operate, or that your bookkeeper operates, rather than someone doing the work for you. That is a different purchase, and it is worth being clear with yourself about which one you are making.
I am not going to publish a feature grid with checkmarks next to other companies' names. Those grids are always written by one of the vendors, they go stale in a quarter, and mine would be no more trustworthy than anyone else's. What I can give you is the test above, and the observation that the answers vary a great deal more than the marketing does.
On FIXE, so you can hold us to the same standard: restaurants are all we do, across 600+ restaurant locations, delivery reconciliation is part of standard monthly close rather than an add on, and the monthly P&L lands within 5 business days of period close. Pricing is published on our site rather than quoted after a discovery call.
Often the right answer. Bring them the delivery reconciliation method and ask for three things: gross sales posted from statements, each deduction in its own account, and payouts tied to the bank monthly. A capable generalist will take that and run with it. If the response is that the deposit is simpler, you have learned something useful.
Delivery reconciliation is a few hours a month of work, so it should not carry a dramatic premium. What it should carry is a commitment: that it happens every month, on the close calendar, with a named owner. A lower fee that leaves delivery to be sorted out at year end is not a saving, because the cost shows up as a food cost number you cannot trust for twelve months.
At 10 percent the errors are still material to your food cost percentage, but a good generalist following a documented method is usually enough. Above roughly 20 percent, the reporting question gets more important than the bookkeeping question.
Integrations pull orders and some fee data. Somebody still has to tie payouts to the bank, handle adjustments and error charges, and decide what is a promotion versus a commission. The last mile is judgment.
It should be inside your normal monthly fee for a single location with two or three platforms. If it is priced separately, ask exactly what the separate work is.
Open last month's P&L. If you cannot see delivery gross sales, commission and promotions as separate lines, the reconciliation is not happening, whatever anyone says.
Different cost structure, different accounting, and it should be a separate channel in your reporting. Averaging the two hides which one works.
Want a fast read on how your delivery numbers are being recorded today? Take the FIXE Health Score quiz.