How to Tell if Your Restaurant Bookkeeper Gets Your Sales Right
Short answer: Your bookkeeper gets your sales right when every dollar your POS and delivery apps report can be traced to a deposit, a fee, a tip payout or a sales tax payment, and nothing is left floating. You can test this yourself: pick one day and trace it from the POS report to the bank, check that delivery sales are booked gross with fees as an expense, confirm tips and sales tax sit on the balance sheet rather than in revenue, and look for clearing accounts or receivables that keep growing. If your bookkeeper can't walk you through those answers, your P&L sales number probably isn't one you should make decisions on.
Sales is the line every other number on your P&L depends on. Food cost percentage, labor percentage, prime cost: they're all divided by sales. If sales is overstated, your costs look better than they are. If it's understated, you'll chase problems that don't exist.
And restaurant sales are messy. The POS says one number, the bank says another, DoorDash pays out net of commissions on its own schedule, and tips and sales tax pass through your accounts without ever being your money. A bookkeeper who doesn't know restaurants will often just book whatever hits the bank as "sales." At FIXE, we do the books for 600+ restaurant locations, and that shortcut is one of the most common problems we find when we take over a new set of books.
Here's how to tell, without being an accountant, whether your bookkeeper is getting this right.
What does "getting sales right" actually mean for a restaurant?
It means your books show what you actually sold, not just what landed in the bank. A correct sales entry for a restaurant usually does four things:
- Records gross sales by category (food, beverage, delivery and so on), as reported by the POS and the delivery platforms.
- Separates out money that isn't yours: sales tax collected and tips owed to staff, which belong on the balance sheet as liabilities.
- Records fees as expenses: card processing fees and delivery app commissions, so you can see what they cost you.
- Ties the net amount to actual deposits, so every expected dollar is either in the bank or explained.
If you want the longer explanation of why sales and deposits never match, read sales and bank deposits are different: account for tax, tips and fees.
What tests can a restaurant owner run on their bookkeeper's sales work?
You don't need to audit the whole year. These checks take an hour or two and tell you most of what you need to know.
| Test | How to run it | What a good answer looks like | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| One-day trace | Pick a recent day. Ask your bookkeeper to show that day's POS sales in the books and the matching card and cash deposits. | Gross sales match the POS; the deposit equals sales plus tax and tips, minus fees, with timing explained. | "Sales" equals the deposit amount |
| Monthly POS tie-out | Compare the POS net sales report for the month to sales on your P&L. | They match, or the difference is listed and explained (comps, voids, gift cards). | An unexplained gap every month |
| Delivery app check | Pull the DoorDash, Uber Eats or Grubhub statement for the month and find it on the P&L. | Delivery sales booked gross; commissions and fees in their own expense account. | Delivery sales booked at the net payout |
| Tips liability | Look at tips payable on your balance sheet. | Rises with credit card tips and falls when payroll pays them out. | Tips in revenue, or a balance that only grows |
| Sales tax liability | Compare sales tax collected in the POS to sales tax payable in the books. | Collected tax goes to a liability and is cleared when you file and pay. | Sales tax inside sales, or payments coded as an expense |
| Clearing accounts and receivables | Ask for the balance of any undeposited funds, clearing or delivery receivable accounts. | Small balances that reflect a few days of payouts in transit. | Balances that grow month after month |
| Bank reconciliation | Ask for the month's bank reconciliation report. | Reconciled to the statement, with few old uncleared items. | No report, or months of uncleared deposits |
Why does my P&L sales number not match my POS?
Some differences are normal. Gift card sales, comps and voids, sales that cross midnight at period end, and how your POS labels "net sales" can all create small gaps. A good bookkeeper knows which of these apply to you and can list them. The problem is a difference nobody can explain, or one that changes direction every month. That usually means sales are being booked from deposits instead of from the POS. For more on this, see demystifying restaurant sales misalignment.
How should a bookkeeper handle delivery app sales?
This is where we see the most mistakes. Delivery platforms pay you a net amount after commissions, marketing fees, refunds and adjustments, usually on a weekly schedule that doesn't line up with your period end. If your bookkeeper books the payout as sales, two things go wrong: your sales are understated and your delivery costs are invisible.
The right approach is to book the gross sales from each platform's statement, record each fee type as an expense, and track what's owed to you as a receivable until the payout lands. That's also how you catch missing payouts, unexpected adjustments and disputed orders. Our DoorDash, Uber Eats and Grubhub reconciliation guide walks through it step by step.
How should tips and sales tax show up in my books?
Neither one is revenue. Credit card tips are money you're holding for your team until payroll pays it out, so they belong in a tips payable account. Sales tax is money you're holding for the state until you file, so it belongs in a sales tax payable account. If either one is sitting in your sales line, your sales are overstated, and your food and labor percentages look better than they really are. Ask your bookkeeper where each one lives. A restaurant bookkeeper will answer immediately. Your CPA or the state can confirm specific filing rules for your location.
What questions should I ask my bookkeeper about sales?
- Where do you get the sales number each period: the POS report or the bank?
- How do you book delivery app sales and fees, and where can I see them?
- What's in our clearing or undeposited funds accounts right now, and why?
- How do you know every card batch made it to the bank?
- When was the last time you found a missing deposit or delivery payout, and what did you do?
Good answers are specific. Vague answers ("we reconcile everything") are a reason to run the tests above. For a broader review of your bookkeeper beyond sales, see how do I know if my restaurant bookkeeper is doing a good job?
How does FIXE reconcile restaurant sales?
FIXE is restaurant bookkeeping software with the bookkeeper included. We keep your books in QuickBooks Online, and our dedicated bookkeeping team reconciles sales, delivery apps and deposits every period, so the reconciled P&L you get within 5 business days of period close is one you can act on. You also get weekly KPIs between closes, AP automation and side-by-side location reporting if you run more than one location.
Pricing is $690 (Essentials), $830 (Pro+) or $1,200+ (Premium) per location per month.
Not sure your sales number is right?
We'll walk through how we reconcile POS, delivery apps, tips and deposits for 600+ restaurant locations.
Book a demoTake the free Health ScoreFrequently asked questions
Should my restaurant's P&L sales match my bank deposits?
No. Deposits include tips and sales tax and are reduced by card and delivery fees, and they arrive on a delay. Your P&L sales should match your POS and delivery platform reports, with deposits reconciled separately.
Should delivery app sales be recorded gross or net?
Gross. Record the full sales amount from the platform's statement and book commissions and fees as an expense. Booking the net payout hides what delivery actually costs you.
How often should my bookkeeper reconcile sales and deposits?
At least every period close, and ideally more often so missing deposits are caught while they're still easy to chase. Weekly reviews make problems smaller.
What is a clearing account and why does it matter?
A clearing account holds money in transit, like card batches or delivery payouts that haven't hit the bank yet. A small balance is normal. A balance that keeps growing usually means deposits aren't being matched to sales.
Can I check my bookkeeper's sales work without accounting knowledge?
Yes. The one-day trace is the easiest test: pick a day, find it in your POS, and ask your bookkeeper to show you where it is in the books and the bank. If they can do that quickly, that's a good sign.
More on Choosing a Restaurant Bookkeeper
- Choosing a Restaurant Bookkeeper: the full guide
- How do I know if my restaurant bookkeeper is doing a good job?
- Demystifying restaurant sales misalignment
- Sales and bank deposits are different: Account for tax, tips + fees
- DoorDash, Uber Eats and Grubhub reconciliation guide
